Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Photography: Three Related Chinese Restaurants in New York City: Far East Tea Garden, Far East Restaurant and City Hall Tea Garden


The Far East Tea Garden was established in 1906 according to its 1941 postcard. The restaurant was located on the second floor of 10 Columbus Circle at West 59th Street. According to The New York Times, December 11, 1953, Childs Restaurant occupied the first floor when it opened on September 3, 1911. At some point there was a billiards parlor on the third floor.


The west side of Columbus Circle was photographed by Geo. P. Hall & Son. On the far left a sign advertised Eddie Foy in The Orchid which opened April 8, 1907 and closed March 2, 1908. In the white box, the trees obscured any signage that may have been attached to the building where Far East Tea Garden was located.


Geo. P. Hall & Son photographed the west side of Columbus Circle again. His photograph appeared on postcards. The postcard, below, was postmarked September 24, 1912. On the left a sign advertised Mimic World which opened on July 9, 1908 and closed October 3, 1908 at the Casino Theatre.

 
The 1908 photograph, in the collection of The New York Historical, was viewed at Digital Culture of Metropolitan New York. Below are details of from the photograph and postcard. On the front of the building, the sign said The Far East Chinese Restaurant. Extending off the front toward West 59th Street, a T-shaped sign said Tea Garden.

 
So far the earliest newspaper mention, I’ve found, of Far East Tea Garden was a classified advertisement in the New York Evening Telegram, September 23, 1909.
Best window, comfortable seats, to let for Hudson-Fulton celebration, on corner 59th and Columbus Circle. Apply Far East Tea Garden.

Far East Tea Garden advertised in a number of newspapers including The New York Shimpo and the New York Evening Telegram.

The New York Shimpo, September 16, 1911
 
New York Evening Telegram 
November 16, 1911

 New York Evening Telegram, November 23, 1912

New York Evening Telegram, April 12, 1913
 
New York Evening Telegram, December 31, 1914
 

New York Evening Telegram, December 31, 1915

The Trow Copartnership and Corporation Directory of the Boroughs of Manhattan and the Bronx, City of New York, March 1912, named the partners of the Far East Tea Garden & Chinese Restaurant, a registered trade name: Loo Lin, Lee Fook and Gong Wye. The 1916  and 1926 directories named the same three men.

Far East Tea Garden was a large restaurant with seating for 200 people. Gong Wye was the manager. Far East Tea Garden postcard had the address Columbus Circle, Broadway, corner 59th Street, New York City.


Photo-illustrations of the Circle Building at Columbus Circle appeared in Hearst’s Magazine (1914), Architecture and Building (August 1915) and Atlantic Terra Cotta (September 1915). Far East Tea Garden was on the far left (red arrows). 

 


In 1916, the Far East Tea Garden Company planned to open a second restaurant at 1628 Broadway and 50th Street. The new branch was called Far East Restaurant. Both locations were added to postcards. (In his 2009 book, Appetite City, William Grimes was incorrect when he said Far East restaurant, at Broadway and Fiftieth Street, opened before Far East Tea Garden at Columbus Circle.)

New York Herald, January 29, 1916

Rider’s New York City (1916) mentioned Far East Tea Garden and Far East Garden.

Another partner was named in Polk & Co.’s 1917 Trow’s General Directory of the Boroughs of Manhattan and the Bronx. Lee Foo who resided at 30 Pell Street. Lee Fook was at 34 Mott Street. The directory listed both businesses, Far East Restaurant Company (1628 Broadway) and Far East Tea Garden & Chinese Restaurant (10 Columbus Circle).
 
 Same image above and below; the typeface changed


In early 1918, Loo Lin partnered with Gong Wye to open the City Hall Tea Garden restaurant at 170 Nassau Street. It was reported in The New York Times, January 11, 1918; Real Estate Record and Builders’ Guide, January 12, 1918; and National Hotel Reporter, January 19, 1918 (below).


City Hall Tea Garden advertised in The Japanese Times in the years 1919, 1920, 1921, 1922, 1923, 1925, 1926, 1928, and 1929.

January 1, 1919
 
At least five employees registered with the draft board during World War I.
 
Young Lee, June 5, 1917.
 
Lew Fong, June 5, 1918.
 
Sik S. Dang, June 5, 1918.
 
Dong Sing, September 12, 1918.

Dung Chuck, September 12, 1918.
 
During the War, Far East Tea Garden donated to the Red Cross.

New York Evening Telegram, May 22, 1918

Trow’s New York Copartnership and Corporation Directory, Boroughs of Manhattan and Bronx, January 1919, listed Loo Lin of the City Hall Tea Garden.

The plan and construction of the Gotham National Bank skyscraper, at 1819 Broadway, began in 1919 and was completed in 1920. Photographs of Gotham National Bank sometimes included Far East Tea Garden.

By 1920 Far East Tea Garden had a horizontal chop suey sign attached to the south end of the building.

 
Better Banks: Terra Cotta Brochure Series Volume Four (1921) included a photograph of the Gotham National Bank Building and, in the lower left, Far East Tea Garden.


Far East Restaurant Company and Far East Tea Garden were included in the 1921 guide book, Visiting New York City.

The film Perjury, with William Farnum, opened in August 1921. The sign for the film was on the far left of Irving Underhill’s photograph of the west side of Columbus Circle.


When William J. Roege photographed Columbus Circle, there was a sign for the film, Footfalls, which was released on September 8, 1921. In the detail, two men were painting the billboard above Far East Tea Garden.


The view from the restaurant can be seen in Underhill’s photograph of the east side.


On August 20, 1921, the restaurant Lindy’s opened, next door to Far East Restaurant, at 1626 Broadway. On the left is the awning of Far East Restaurant. (The Wurts Bros. photograph of Lindy’s is in the collection of the Museum of the City of New York.)

 
City Hall Tea Garden was burgled according to the Evening World, August 22, 1921.

In Irving Underhill’s 1922 photograph of the Gotham National Bank Building, Far East’s vertical chop suey was visible (yellow box).  

 
The New York Morning Telegraph, August 29, 1922, reported the fight at the Far East Tea Garden.


The brawl at City Hall Tea Garden was covered by the New York Evening Telegram, May 25, 1923.


City Hall Tea Garden was included in the tea room chapter of Adventuring in New York (1923). 

Electrical Record, November 1923, published nighttime photograph of the Gotham Bank Building. At the bottom was the top of Far East’s illuminated sign (yellow arrow).


The American Bankers Association Journal, March 1924, included an advertisement for the National Terra Cotta Society. The photograph featured the Gotham National Bank and, on the lower left, Far East Tea Garden.

 
A photograph of Columbus Circle and Eighth Avenue was taken on October 22, 1925. Far East Garden’s illuminated chop suey sign was two stories tall.


Gotham National Bank merged with Manufacturers’ Trust Company in 1925. Below is a detail of the March 4, 1926 photograph of Columbus Circle.

 
Illustrirte Zeitung, March 17, 1927, published a photo-essay on New York City. The illuminated letters of Far East Garden appeared on the far left of the Columbus Circle photograph (detail below).


Around 1928, Columbus Circle was photographed from an aerial view. Far East Tea Garden building was to the right of the Camels cigarette billboard.
 
 
Towers of Manhattan (1928) included J.W. Golinkin’s drawing of the former Gotham National Building.  Far East Tea Garden was the building on the left.


Polk’s Trow’s New York Copartnership and Corporation Directory, Boroughs of Manhattan and the Bronx, 1930
, listed City Hall Tea Garden, Far East Restaurant and Far East Tea Garden.

In 1931 the Byron Company photographed the Manufacturers’ Trust Company at Columbus Circle. Several business were captured including Far East Tea Garden.

 
Far East Tea Garden had a listing in Polk’s New York City (Manhattan and Bronx) Directory, 1933–1934. City Hall Tea Garden and Far East Restaurant were not listed and evidently out of business possibly due to the Depression. (The Varsity Casino replaced Far East Restaurant; see New York City Municipal Archives, 1939–1941.)
 
In Tips on Tables (1934), George Ross commented on Far East Tea Garden.
In this stronghold of the Orient you may order anything Chinese your heart desires and rest assured that it will be both authentic and palatable. This walk-up-one-flight establishment was serving chow mein, etc., long before that dish was synonymous with cheap jazz bands and dancing couples consisting solely of females. Although redecorated recently, the Far East has not made concessions to jazz or, happily enough, to its quality of food. The chicken and pineapple chow mein is delicious, and so is the egg roll—a light, fine-textured substance that melts effortlessly in your mouth. The prices are reasonable, and the place is open until three o’clock every morning.
Around 1934 a billboard space was prepared at Columbus Circle. In the photograph detail, the full length of Far East’s illuminated sign showed the word suey aligned with the second floor windows.

 
Dining in New York with Rector (1939) had George Rector’s view of Far East Tea Garden.
Open: Noon to 9 P.M. Lunch: 45¢ Dinner: 65¢ One of the oldest and most popular of the uptown Chinese places is this one on Columbus Circle. The usual modest Chinese prices are charged; dinner may go up to eighty-five cents, but even ordering à la carte at odd hours cannot make it very expensive. The cuisine is really Chinese-American, which may be why so many Americans find themselves so much at home here.
In 1935 Far East Tea Garden changed its name to Far East Restaurant. It ordered new postcards from the Curt Teich Company in Chicago. The restaurant remodeled in 1941 and ordered new postcards (below). On December 11, 1941, Mike Gold, a Daily Worker columnist, mentioned the new decor.


Between the years 1939 and 1941, every building was photographed for the New York City Tax Department. The photograph of Far East Restaurant was labeled 9 Columbus Circle. In the detail below, a vertical chop suey neon sign was flat on the face of the building. On the West 59th Street side, I believe, the neon sign said Far East Garden.


Manhattan telephone directories included Far East Restaurant and Far East Tea Garden, at 10 Columbus Circle, in 1940, 1946, and 1953–1954 (below).


In April 1954, Angelo Rizzuto photographed Columbus Circle from Central Park. His photograph was taken days or weeks before the demolition to make way for the New York Coliseum. It’s not clear if Far East Restaurant was open in April. The New York Times, December 11, 1953, said Childs Restaurant, at Columbus Circle, served its last meal on November 30, 1953.

Most of the letters of Far East are visible.
 
The New York Times, June 22, 1954, published an aerial view of the construction site which was photographed by Meyer Liebowitz of the Times on June 21. The Coliseum opened in April 1956. 10 Columbus Circle was the address of the New York Coliseum Tower.


 
The location of Far East Restaurant is in the red circle.
 
Postcard from the 1970s
 
The Chinese-American Times, July 1, 1960, reported Loo Lin’s visit.
Oldtimer, 94, Returns
New York—Loo Lin, 94, one of the first Chinese settlers of the Eastern US, enjoyed a recent four-day visit to the city where he lived and worked as a young man in the 1880s.

He returned to the sites of his former restaurants, at 14 Mott St., the City Hall Tea Garden on Nassau St. and the Far East Tea Garden on Columbus Circle. In his search for old cronies, Mr. Loo learned that many had died. He was especially happy visiting one of his oldest friends, Miss Mary Banta of True Light Lutheran Church.

Loo Lin retired in the late 30s and lived in the US during World War II, returning to Canton in 1947. He lived through ten years of Communism, coming out of the China mainland in August, 1959. He journeyed to the US in March, 1960.

During his Eastern sojourn, Mr. Loo stayed with his son, David Lu, who is employed by the government in Washington, DC. He now lives in Sacramento, Calif, with a daughter.
 
Far East Tea Garden was listed in the following books.
Rider’s New York City (1916)
Who’s Who of the Chinese in New York (1918)
Nightlife (1931)
New York, the Giant City: An Introduction to New York (1939)

 
SIDEBAR: Chinese Food, Artists and Authors
A number of artists are known to have dined at Far East Tea Garden including Gifford Beal (interior color study and etching), and photographer Alfred Stieglitz, his wife, Georgia O’Keeffe (married in 1924) and his friends. Max Weber was a friend of Stieglitz but they had a falling out in 1911. Weber created Chinese Restaurant in 1915. Edward Hopper and his wife, Josephine, were customers, too. He used Far East’s illuminated sign as reference for his 1929 painting, “Chop Suey”.


The American Diaries, 1902–1926 (1983) was a collection of Theodore Dreiser’s diaries. In 1917 he dined, at least seven times, in Far East Garden. It’s not known if Sinclair Lewis or O. Henry dined at Far East Tea Garden. Lewis mentioned chop suey in Our Mr. Wrenn (1914), “Honestly If Possible” (1916 short story), Main Street (1920), Babbitt (1922), and Bethel Merriday (1940). Chop suey was mentioned by O. Henry in “A Madison Square Arabian Night” and “One Thousand Dollars”.


(Next post on Wednesday: This Week in Chicago, 1931)

No comments:

Post a Comment